Comparison of Peptide Synthesis Methods and Techniques

Synthesis of peptides is a complex process that usually involves different synthesis strategies and techniques. The following are some common approaches to peptide synthesis processes and techniques:

Solid-Phase Synthesis

This is one of the most commonly used methods for peptide synthesis. It is based on the stepwise addition of amino acid units on a solid-phase support to build peptide chains. The solid phase support materials typically used are highly reactive resins such as Rink-Amide or Fmoc-AM resin. During the synthesis process, the amino acid unit is immobilized on the solid phase by a reactive protecting group, followed by coupling, deprotection and elution to finally obtain the target peptide.

Solution-Phase Synthesis

This method synthesizes peptides in solution. It is usually applied to shorter peptide chains. In solution-phase synthesis, the amino acid unit is coupled to other amino acids in a coupling reaction via an activator (e.g., an activated acid or an activated carboxylic acid). After the reaction, steps such as removal of protective groups and purification are required to obtain a pure peptide product.

Chemical Synthesis

Chemical synthesis is a technique for synthesizing peptide by methods of organic synthesis. It usually involves a reaction using chemical reagents such as protecting groups, activators and solvents. Chemical synthesis methods can be used to synthesize complex peptide structures, but are more challenging for long chain peptides due to the number of steps and the potential for side reactions.

Biosynthesis

Biosynthesis is the synthesis of peptides using cellular mechanisms and enzymes in the organism. This method is commonly used in the synthesis of natural peptides, such as in the production of hormones and peptide drugs. Through genetic engineering techniques, genes encoding peptide are introduced into appropriate expression systems to synthesize the target peptide within the cell.

These synthetic methods are widely used in the field of peptide drugs. Each method has its advantages and limitations, and the choice of synthesis depends on factors such as peptide structural complexity, target purity requirements, scale and economics. Researchers choose the most suitable synthesis strategy and technique based on the specific synthesis needs.

TypeSynthesis methodAdvantageDisadvantage
Chemical SynthesisSolution-Phase SynthesisHigh purity, easy purification, low costComplex, cumbersome and time-consuming
Solid-Phase SynthesisSimplified reactions, automation, reduced lossesShorter synthesis sequence, longer synthesis time time, higher purity, higher cost, shorter synthesis sequence lower purity and higher cost, Reagent toxicity
Fermentation methodlow costNarrow application range, difficult to separateDifficult to isolate and purify
BiosynthesisGenetic recombination methodStrong expressive directionality, High safety and costLow costNot easy to separate, yield Low, not easy to scale up production
Enzymatic hydrolysisMild reaction conditions, High selectivityDifficult to separate, low yield Low yield

What  is Solid-Phase Synthesis?

Currently, solid-phase synthesis is the mainstay of peptide drug synthesis processes. The synthesis process of peptide drugs is mainly categorized into chemical synthesis method and biosynthesis method in consideration of technology application, production process, production cost, quality management and environmental protection requirements.

The chemical synthesis method is mainly used to synthesize peptide through amino acid condensation reaction. Such methods include solid-phase synthesis and solution-phase synthesis. The solid-phase synthesis method is mainly used for the synthesis of medium-length peptides, which is based on the gradual addition of amino acid units on a solid-phase support to build peptide chains. The solution-phase synthesis method is mainly used for the synthesis of short peptides, in which the amino acid units are coupled to other amino acids by activators in a coupling reaction.

Biosynthesis includes enzymatic hydrolysis, fermentation and genetic engineering methods. These methods utilize cellular mechanisms and enzymes in the organism to synthesize peptides. Enzymatic hydrolysis is the enzymatic cleavage of raw peptides into target peptides by the action of enzymes. Fermentation is used to synthesize peptides through the process of fermentation by microorganisms. The genetic engineering method utilizes genetic engineering techniques to introduce the gene encoding the target peptide into an appropriate expression system that will synthesize the target peptide within the cell.

At present, the solid-phase synthesis method is relatively mature, and most of the marketed peptide drugs use this process route. This is due to the advantages of solid-phase synthesis for peptide synthesis, which offers a high degree of control, high yields and high purity. However, with the continuous development and improvement of biosynthesis technology, biosynthesis also has a broad application prospect in the synthesis of peptide drugs.

Solid-phase synthesis is currently the most commonly used peptide synthesis process, which has become quite mature after years of development. In 1963, Merrifield proposed the classical solid-phase peptide synthesis (SPPS) method, a milestone that marked a new era in peptide synthesis. After decades of improvement and refinement, the solid-phase synthesis has formed a mature process with the Boc method and the Fmoc method as the main systems.

The core idea of the solid-phase synthesis is to combine the carboxyl group of the first amino acid of the target peptide with a solid-phase carrier (usually a resin) through covalent bonding. Then, starting with the amino group of that amino acid, the acylation reaction is carried out by removing the aminoprotecting group and the excess carboxyl group of the second amino acid. This step is repeated over and over again, resulting in the target peptide.

The main difference between the different solid-phase synthesis methods is the amine protecting group used. The Boc method uses Boc as the amino protecting group, while the side chain protecting group is usually a benzyl alcohol compound. The Fmoc method, on the other hand, uses Fmoc as the aminoprotecting group. Compared with the Boc method, the Fmoc method has the advantages of stable acidity, mild reaction conditions, fewer side reactions, and higher yields, so it has been widely used in the field of peptide solid-phase synthesis.

The advantage of the solid-phase synthesis is that it simplifies and automates the subsequent processing of each step. It avoids manual handling and losses in material transfer. However, the solid-phase synthesis has some drawbacks, such as shorter synthesis sequences, longer time-consumption, lower product purity, higher cost, and higher toxicity of reagents.

Difference Between Boc and Fmoc Methods

The Boc method and the Fmoc method are two amino-protected group methods commonly used in solid-phase synthesis, and they have some specific differences in peptide synthesis, as shown below:

  1. Amino Protecting Group

Boc method (t-Butyloxycarbonyl): The Boc protecting group is obtained by reacting t-Butanol acid with the amino group of an amino acid, protecting the amino group of the amino acid. This protective group is stable under alkaline conditions and can be removed under strongly acidic conditions.

Fmoc method (Fluorenylmethyloxycarbonyl): The Fmoc protecting group is obtained by reacting the amino group of an amino acid with Fmoc-Cl, which also protects the amino group of the amino acid. Fmoc protecting groups are stable under acidic conditions and can be removed under alkaline conditions.

  • De-protection Methods

Boc Methods: Boc protective groups can be removed under strong acidic conditions. Commonly used deprotection reagents are acids, such as trifluoroacetic acid (TFA). The process of removing the Boc protecting group requires the use of organic solvents such as dimethylformamide (DMF) or dichloromethane (DCM).

Fmoc method: Fmoc protective groups can be removed under alkaline conditions. Commonly used deprotection reagents are alkaline solutions, such as alkaline acetone (piperidine) solution. The process of removing Fmoc protecting groups usually requires the use of organic solvents such as N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) or dichloromethane (DCM).

  • Photosensitivity

Boc method: The Boc protecting group is not photosensitive, so photolithography operations can be performed using UV light under the Boc method.

Fmoc method: The Fmoc protecting group is photosensitive and photolytic reaction occurs when exposed to UV light, so protection and deprotection operations under photosensitizing conditions are required under the Fmoc method.

  • Reaction Conditions

Boc method: The reaction conditions under the Boc method are relatively mild and suitable for general amino acid condensation reactions.

Fmoc method: The reaction conditions under the Fmoc method are also relatively mild, and it is suitable for general amino acid condensation reactions, but it is necessary to pay attention to the characteristics of the photosensitive protective group.

Overall, the Boc and Fmoc methods differ in their aminoprotecting groups and deprotection methods, and the choice of which method to use depends on the specific synthetic needs and conditions. In practical applications, the Fmoc method has become one of the more commonly used methods in solid-phase synthesis of peptides due to its advantages of acidic stability and few side reactions.

What is Solution-Phase Synthesis?

Solution-phase synthesis is a widely used method for peptide synthesis with obvious advantages and disadvantages.

The solution-phase synthesis can be subdivided into stepwise and segmented synthesis methods. Stepwise synthesis usually starts from the C-terminus of the peptide and adds amino acids one by one until the target peptide is synthesized. This method is generally applicable to the synthesis of short peptides or various bioactive peptide fragments. Segmental synthesis is a fast developing peptide synthesis method in recent years, and its chemical specificity has a prominent role in the field of long peptide synthesis. The core idea of the segmental synthesis method is to rationally divide the target peptide into a number of fragments, and after synthesizing these fragments, carry out linkage and condensation to finally obtain the target peptide. The major linkage modes for segmental synthesis include natural chemical linkage, chemical regioselective linkage, removable auxiliary group linkage, light-sensitive auxiliary group linkage, Staudinger linkage, and orthogonal chemical linkage.

Solution-phase synthesis offers many advantages such as high purity, ease of purification and lower cost. However, it is also somewhat complex and cumbersome, requiring time and effort. At the same time, the segmental synthesis technique has limitations in its application because it is based on natural chemical linkages, which must depend on cysteine (Cys) residues.

Solution-phase synthesis is a widely used method for peptide synthesis with the advantages of high purity, easy purification and lower cost. Segmental synthesis, as one of the strategies, is rapidly developing in the field of long peptide synthesis, which improves the efficiency and specificity of synthesis by rationally segmenting the target peptide and selecting the appropriate linkage. However, the solution-phase synthesis method has some challenges such as high complexity, cumbersome operation, time consumption, and the application of the segmental synthesis is limited by cysteine residues.

Common Methods for Solution-phase Synthesis

  1. Natural Chemical Connection

Natural chemical connection are those that utilize chemical reactions between natural amino acids in two fragments. The most common natural chemical connection is the formation of a connection through an amide bond between an amine group (N-terminal) and a carboxyl group (C-terminal). This connection is made through a nucleophilic substitution reaction between the amine group and the carboxyl group, in which the nitrogen atom of the amine group attacks the carbon atom of the carboxyl group to produce an amide bond. Natural chemical connection methods are widely used in peptide synthesis because they are reliable, efficient, and have good compatibility.

  • Chemical Region Selection Connection

Chemical region selection connection refers to the joining of unnatural chemical regions in two fragments of a peptide by selecting a specific chemical reaction between the two fragments. This linkage method does not rely on the way natural amino acids are linked to each other, but rather utilizes specific reactions between non-natural chemical groups in the fragments to occur the linkage. Common Chemical region selection connection methods include the use of specific functional groups, protecting groups, and ligands to achieve the linkage. This connection method can occur in specific chemical environments and is highly selective and specific, making it useful in the synthesis of complex peptides or peptides containing unnatural chemical groups.

  • Removable Auxiliary Group Connection

The removable auxiliary group connection is a method of realizing a Connection by introducing a removable auxiliary group. These auxiliary groups can be easily removed after the connection is complete, leaving no trace. Commonly used methods of removable auxiliary group connection include the use of acrylic auxiliary groups and ester auxiliary groups. After the connection is completed, the target peptide can be obtained by cleavage of the auxiliary group through appropriate conditions, such as acidic or basic conditions.

  • Light-sensitive Auxiliary Group Connection

Light-sensitive auxiliary group connection is a method that utilizes a light-sensitive compound as an auxiliary group, and the linkage occurs under the illumination of light at a specific wavelength. This connection method utilizes the photoactivity of the photosensitive compound to activate the auxiliary group by light to make the connection to another fragment. The light-sensitive auxiliary group connection method is highly spatially and temporally controllable, allows connection to be realized under specific conditions, and avoids the use of other chemical reagents.

  • Staudinger Connection

A Staudinger connection is a method of making a connection through the use of a Staudinger reaction. The Staudinger reaction is a chemical reaction in which a new bond is formed between two functional groups. In peptide synthesis, the Staudinger linkage can be used to connect unnatural amino acid residues in two fragments. This linkage method has been widely used in the field of peptide synthesis.

  • Orthogonal chemical Connection

Orthogonal chemical connection is a method of achieving linkage through the use of highly selective chemical reactions. These reactions enable interference-free linkage of fragments in peptide synthesis, i.e., connection occurs only with the target fragment and not with other functional groups under specific conditions. The advantage of this connection method is that the connection can be realized in a complex chemical environment, avoiding the occurrence of side reactions.

What is Biosynthesis?

Enzymatic Hydrolysis

This is a method for degrading large proteins into active peptides through the use of biological enzymes. This method can maintain the natural properties of peptides and retain the original nutritional value of proteins, and is commonly used in food, cosmetic, feed and other industries. However, the peptides obtained after enzymatic hydrolysis are unsuitable for the synthesis of specific peptide sequences because of the difficulty in separating them. Therefore, enzymatic hydrolysis is not a commonly used method in the field of peptide synthesis.

Fermentation Method

This is a method method of obtaining a natural peptide by a metabolic process of a microorganism. The production cost of this method is low, but its application is more limited. Currently, the main peptides that can be synthesized independently by fermentation method include ε-polylysine (ε-PL), γ-polyglutamic acid (γ-PGA), and cyanobacterial peptides.

Genetic Engineering Method

Peptides are synthesized by controlling the DNA template using DNA recombination technology. This method is suitable for the preparation of long peptides. The genetic engineering method has the advantages of strong expression targeting, high safety and low cost. However, it also has some drawbacks, such as a long development cycle, difficulty in isolation, low yield, and difficulty in large-scale production. Enzymatic hydrolysis is mainly used in food, cosmetic, feed and other industries; fermentation method is suitable for obtaining specific peptides, but the scope of application is narrower; genetic engineering method is suitable for the preparation of long peptides, which has certain advantages and disadvantages. In the field of peptide synthesis, the commonly used methods are ribosomal translation and chemical synthesis, which enable the synthesis and customization of specific peptide sequences.